Are genetically modified trees a threat to forests. Genetically modified gm trees are woody plants improved through recombinant dna technology. Considering the fast pace of new advances in production of genetically modified. For all these reasons, resistance to genetically engineered trees has been strong, with the campaign to stop ge trees leading the charge. Global justice ecology project coordinates, administrates and fundraises for the campaign. In just five and a half years they are 27 metres high. Genetically modified organisms gmos are organisms that have been transformed by the insertion of one or more isolated genes. Most rennet used today is commercially produced by genetically modified microorganisms most commonly with gm fungi. Nov 15, 2012 the company says its modified eucalyptus trees can grow 5 metres 16ft a year, with 20%30% more mass than a normal eucalyptus. And because trees live for years, that adds up to a lot of intimate interaction with the natural world. Genetically modified tree wikipedia republished wiki 2. The restriction on the usage of genetically modified trees has been adopted based on the precautionary principle.
Genetically engineered trees in canada research to genetically engineer trees is an immediate environmental threat. T oday, the number of forest tree species for which transformation and. The most controversial tree in the world pacific standard. But in reality, they pose an even greater threat because they impact directly on natural forests that are essential for the survival of our planet. Aug 08, 2017 brazil approved a genetically modified eucalyptus, created by biotechnology company futuragene, for commercial growth two years ago. Read current science articles on genetic engineering including mice with glowing hearts. Genetically modified trees discussion document 4, october 2017 by sergio baffoni and mandy haggith, epn this discussion document, by staff members of epn, is intended to foster dialogue regarding a key issue of concern or an opportunity for advancing the goals of. Byrne modified genetically through domestication from wild species and many generations. The potential environmental, cultural and socioeconomic. The largest fieldbased study of genetically modified forest trees ever conducted has demonstrated that genetic engineering can prevent new seedlings from establishing.
In this study, a comparative analysis of the bacterial and archaeal communities found in the rhizosphere of genetically modified gm versus wildtype wt poplar was conducted on trees at different growth stages i. These nutrients which may be stress tolerant are introduced in the gmo. They are conferred with useful traits to lower production costs of wood products, increase productivity, and improve the economics of tree plantations through creation of suitable raw materials, decreased pesticide use, disease resistance, and. Lignin is a key structural component of plant cell walls and a major. Another world is possible whether the gm tree industry likes it. Under the misleading name of reforestation, which sounds quite nice, huge plantations of exotic and even genetically engineered trees have been set. Will a genetically modified tree harm the environment. One activist concern is that pollen or seeds from genetically modified trees could cross over and contaminate a nonge forest. Todays recombinant dna techniques allow scientists to transfer desirable traits more rapidly, pre. Genetically modified foods massachusetts medical society. A genetically modified tree gmt, gm tree, genetically engineered tree, ge tree or transgenic tree is a tree whose dna has been modified using genetic engineering techniques. However, the effect of using genetically modified organisms for phytoremediation is a poorly researched topic in terms of microbial community structures, despite the important role of microorganisms in the health.
The same techniques could be adapted to biofuel production, helping lessen our reliance. List of genetically engineered tree species and transgenic hybrids. But this would become the first genetically engineered tree. Groundbreaking poplar study shows trees can be genetically. Pdf genetically modified organisms gmos as invasive. Trees such as eucalyptus, american chestnut, poplar and pine are being genetically engineered for traits including faster growth, insect and disease resistance, and altered wood composition. The first field trials of ge trees were started in belgium in 1988 when researchers began to develop ge poplars which were genetically modified to be resistant to herbicides. Genetically modified plants for food use and human healthan. Genetically modified is an imprecise term and a potentially confusing one, in that virtually everything we eat has been by p. A elkassaby and others published forests and genetically modified trees find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate.
Epa approval of genetically modified corn in 1995, the epa for the first time approved the marketing of a genetically engineered cropa variety of corn bred to be insect resistant. Environmentalists yesterday warned of the dangers of genetically modified super trees which can cross pollinate with native trees over a distance of 400 miles and which are being grown in field. Genetically modified gm forest trees do not attract the same immediate health concerns as gm food crops. The campaign to stop ge trees is an international alliance of organizations that united in 2004 to stop the release of genetically engineered trees in order to prevent the anticipated ecologically and socially devastating impacts. No single corporation with deep pockets is behind the creation of. A genetically modified tree doesnt necessarily come with all the baggage of genetically modified organisms in breakfast cereal. But gases emitted by some trees, like poplars, can react with tailpipe emissions, harm human health and contribute to global warming. Lignin is the critical limiting factor when using wood to make bioethanol because lignin limits the accessibility of cellulose microfibrils to depolymerization by enzymes. Until enough scientific data on genetically modified trees indicates or guarantee that impacts on human and animal health and the environment are equivalent to, or more positive. Genetically modified trees discussion document 4, october 2017 by sergio baffoni and mandy haggith, epn this discussion document, by staff members of epn, is intended to foster dialogue regarding a key issue of concern or an opportunity for advancing the goals of the environmental paper networks global paper vision. Ethical considerations regarding genetically modified trees 163 c. Biotechnology is providing us with a wide range of options for how we can use agricultural and commercial forestry lands. Dwarf trees are more productive than traditionalsize trees and offer growers other advantages as well. Pine grows so quickly that its profitable to have tree farms in which pine and other conifer trees are planted, allowed to grow several years, harvested, and new trees planted there are tree nurseries to create.
Suzuki explains how the issues concerning genetic engineering revolves around using horizontal gene transfers, as opposed to vertical gene transfers, to create the genetic abominations. Genetically modified trees, such as the poplar tree, has been. Genetically modified crops gmcs, gm crops, or biotech crops are plants used in agriculture, the dna of which has been modified using genetic engineering techniques. The company says its modified eucalyptus trees can grow 5 metres 16ft a year, with 20%30% more mass than a normal eucalyptus. Some trees have been genetically modified to either have less lignin, or to express lignin with chemically labile bonds. The first genetically engineered dwarf pear tree of an existing variety has been developed by agricultural research service scientists. Regulation of genetically modified trees the society of american foresters saf supports and encourages scientific advancements in forest tree biotechnology and its use to improve forest productivity, wood quality and forest health, including the use of appropriately regulated genetically modified organisms gmos. Far from the tree normally, when an apple is cut or bitten into, the exposed part will slowly brown. This natural browning is caused by an enzyme that produces melanin, polyphenol.
Proponents of genetically engineered trees say biotechnology can help reverse. While some studies show that these engineered foods are as safe as traditionally grown foods, other studies show deleterious effects in animals. The first genetically modified tree, a poplar, was produced 20 years ago fillatti et al. Its one thing to convince an island of 10,000 people, already terrified of lyme disease, to accept the risks that might come with releasing these genetically modified mice into their environment. The royal society report, genetically modified plants for food use 1998, concludedthat the use of genetically modified gm plants potentially offered benefits in agricultural practice, food quality, nutrition and health, but that there were several aspects of gm technology which required further consideration. Social, legal and regulatory issues related to transgenic trees 203 r. The esf american chestnut project has developed an american chestnut tree with a genetically modified resistance to a blight that decimated the trees in. Traditionally, this substance was derived from the stomachs of calves. An invasive nonnative species is any nonnative animal or plant. Genetically modified foods have been around for about two decades and are deemed generally safe, yet they continue to generate controversy. Difazio2 and richard meilan2 poplars genus populus have emerged as a model organism for forest biotechnology, and genetic modification gm. Science finds a way to bring back the american chestnut tree. If they are successful, the tree would be the first genetically modified organism released with the goal of reintroducing an endangered species to the wild, rather than producing a commercial.
Genetically modified poplar trees emit fewer hydrocarbons. Greener paper through genetically engineered trees genetic. Research on ge poplar trees continues in canada and the us. Genetically modified foods have seeped into the daily diet in the united states. Apr 26, 2014 view this video to see how futuragene. Genetically engineered trees are easier to process into pulp, making tree farming less resourceintensive. Chymosin, the primary component of rennet, is the milkclotting enzyme used to make cheese and other dairy products. Genetically modified trees and associated environmental concerns 177 m. The cultivation of genetically modified gm crops on millions of hectares of lands and their injection into our food chain is a huge global genetic experiment involving all living beings. Genetically modified foods st figure 51 antigm protesters attacking a field of geneticallymodified maize in southwestern france.
The present note has been prepared in line with these guidelines. Any way you slice it, a rotten idea problematic gmo apple, should it come to market. In july 2004, hundreds of activists opposed to gm crops destroyed plants being tested by the us biotech company pioneer hibred international. Often, but not always, the transferred genes have been derived from a species different from the recipient. The ultimate threat to forests that is the aim of this book. The companies push into genetically modified trees, led by their joint biotech venture, arborgen llc, looks to overcome several hurdles for the first time. Jan 11, 2017 its one thing to convince an island of 10,000 people, already terrified of lyme disease, to accept the risks that might come with releasing these genetically modified mice into their environment. The consumers of gec also benefited from this technique of farming since they can gain more nutrients. In most cases the aim is to introduce a novel trait to the plant which does not occur naturally within the species. Forests in danger from gm supertree says wwf the guardian. Another genetic engineering first by judy mcbride july 2, 1999.
Genetically modified trees mnn mother nature network. Genetically modified plants for food use and human health. This paper frames genetically modified organisms gmos as invasive species. If released commercially, these ge trees risk contaminating native forests, damaging ecosystems and harming communities due to the following. Developed and used since 1999, this genetically modified papaya, which resists the virus, has saved hawaiis papaya industry. Brazil approved a genetically modified eucalyptus, created by biotechnology company futuragene, for commercial growth two years ago. On the subject of genetically modified trees, reliable information is needed to distinguish facts from emotions. The term genetically modified gm, as it is commonly used, refers to the transfer. Instead, trees are being genetically engineered for a range of purposes aimed to accelerate largescale, industrial monoculture tree plantations and increase profits for biotechnology companies as well as paper, biofuel, lumber, and energy industries.
Examples include resistance to certain pests, diseases, environmental conditions, and herbicide. Genetically modified tree wikimili, the free encyclopedia. Some experts say that these genetically modified trees are even more environmentallydamaging than gm foods. Effect of genetically modified poplars on soil microbial. Even in an agricultural context, trees provide food and shelter for insects, fungi, birds, and mammals. The gm tree plantations bred to satisfy the worlds energy. Most of our food crops have been developed using traditional genetic modification techniques through plant breeding. Jan 29, 2010 the companies push into genetically modified trees, led by their joint biotech venture, arborgen llc, looks to overcome several hurdles for the first time.
Genetic modification of trees faces forest of protests. The term genetically modified food refers to crop plants created for human and animal consumption that use the latest molecular biology. Genetically modified organisms gmos refer broadly to organisms that are produced when selected individual genes are transferred from a given donor organism into another target organism, typically conferring desired properties to the new organism. The lignin of poplar trees would be modified so the wood is less intensive to break down for paper products and biofuels. The firstever genetically engineered ge, also called genetically modified tree was approved in canada in 2015. New genetically modified tree approved by usda with no.
268 536 590 1482 835 896 215 834 645 1222 896 495 1507 1063 315 67 1032 911 529 825 557 965 586 861 1536 489 1108 254 1405 1280 489 261 1377 577 723 676 1248 953 408 454 374 738 1319 924 1270